I think our issue is our lack of movement and lack of numbers in midfield, whenever any of our back four have the ball they don't seem to have any options on for a short pass so they are forced to go long (Cooper in particular has gone back to the 50 yard diagonal up to a hopelessly out numbered and out jumped Bradshaw) hence we can't retain the ball for longer than 3-4 passes!
I'd play a midfield 3 of Billy/Savile/Styles or Shackleton in a 4-3-1-2, with Esse playing in the number 10 behind Bradshaw/Flemming or Burke.
The number 10 needs to be able pick that through ball in to the box, Esse looks like he has that in his locker.